How to Rebrand a Company: A Step-by-Step Strategy From Our Studio
Cracker Barrel changed its logo in August 2025 and changed it back within days. Here is how to plan a rebrand so yours does not end the same way.

In August 2025 Cracker Barrel swapped its old logo, the "Old Timer" leaning on a barrel, for a plain wordmark. In the days that followed, the company lost close to $100 million in market value, the internet was furious, and on 26 August it announced the old logo was coming back. A drawing from 1977 turned out to be worth more to its customers than anyone in the boardroom had guessed.
So how do you rebrand a company without that happening to you? Work out exactly why you are changing, find the parts of your current brand that customers already value, keep or rebuild those on purpose, test the new identity with real people, and roll it out with a plan. The rest of this guide is how we handle each of those steps in our studio, along with the famous rebrands that show what happens when one gets skipped.
What a rebrand actually is
A rebrand is any change big enough that customers notice your business looks or sounds different. At one end sits a refresh: a cleaner logo, updated colours, new photography. At the other end sits a full rebrand with a new name, a new place in the market and a new identity built from scratch.
Most companies need something in between. A lot of founders come to us asking for a "complete rebrand" when what they really need is a sharper version of what they already have. Others ask for a "new logo" when the real problem is that nobody understands what they sell. Getting this right at the start saves more money than any other decision in the project.
Step 1: Be honest about why you are rebranding
Write the reason down in one sentence before anyone opens a design file. Good reasons sound like this: we have outgrown our name, we merged with another company, our customers have changed, our brand looks cheaper than our product, or we are moving into a market where our current identity does not travel.
Weak reasons sound like this: the new marketing head wants to make a mark, a competitor just rebranded, or everyone in the office is bored of the logo. Your customers see your brand far less often than you do, so the fatigue you feel is rarely shared by them.
If you cannot point to a business problem that the rebrand solves, we would usually tell you to wait.
Step 2: Audit what your customers already recognise
Every brand that has been around for a while owns a few things in people's heads. It might be a colour, a character, the shape of a pack or a jingle. These are the cues that make you easy to find on a shelf or in a scroll, and they took years to build.
Tropicana learned this the expensive way. In 2009 the Arnell Group redesigned the Tropicana Pure Premium carton and removed the orange with a straw stuck in it, replacing it with a glass of juice on a white background and a vertical logo. Shoppers could not find their usual juice. Reports put the sales drop at around 20 percent in two months, the old carton was back about six weeks after the new one appeared, and the losses have been estimated at $30 million.
Before you change anything, list your recognisable assets and ask customers which ones they actually notice. Then decide, one at a time, whether each one stays, evolves or goes. If something goes, there should be a reason you can explain.
Step 3: Decide between a refresh and a full rebrand
Once you know why you are changing and what you already own, the size of the job usually becomes obvious.
- A refresh, when the business and its customers are the same but the identity looks dated or works badly on screens.
- A partial rebrand, when you are adding products or markets and the old identity needs to stretch.
- A full rebrand, when the name, the offer or the audience has changed so much that the old brand tells the wrong story.
Burger King is a good example of a refresh done well. In 2021 Jones Knowles Ritchie gave it its first full identity overhaul in about 20 years. Instead of inventing something new, they went back to the brand's own look from 1969 to 1994. The logo was redrawn, a custom typeface called Flame was made with Colophon Foundry, and the colours were pulled from the food itself. It felt new and familiar at once, and that balance is the hardest thing in rebranding to get right.
Step 4: Do the strategy work before the design work
This is the step that rushed projects skip. Before we sketch a single logo, we want written answers to a few questions. Who exactly is the customer now? Why should they pick you over the next option? What do you want people to feel and say about you in three years? What will you never do?
Those answers become the brief. A designer with a clear brief makes better decisions, and a client with a clear brief can judge the work on something other than personal taste. Without one, the logo review turns into a debate about favourite colours.
If you are changing your name, naming happens here too, along with trademark and domain checks. Do not fall in love with a name until a lawyer has looked at it.
Step 5: Design the whole identity system
A logo on its own is a small part of a brand. What people actually experience is everything around it: colours, typefaces, photography style, icons, layouts, packaging, tone of voice, and the rules that keep it all consistent.
We design the system and try it on real applications early: a website header, an Instagram post, a product label, an invoice, a delivery van. A logo that looks great on a presentation slide can fall apart at 32 pixels or on a dark background. You want to find that out before launch.
By the end of this stage you should have the full identity and a set of brand guidelines that anyone on your team, or at your printer, can follow without calling you.
Step 6: Test it with the people who pay you
You do not need a big research budget. Show the new identity to a handful of loyal customers, a few people who have never heard of you, and your own frontline staff. Ask what the brand says to them, whether they would still recognise you, and what feels missing.
Jaguar is the cautionary case here. Its "Copy Nothing" rebrand, launched in late 2024 with Accenture Song, dropped the leaping cat badge for a plain wordmark and released a launch film with no cars in it. The backlash was immediate. To be fair, the awful sales figures that followed, 49 new cars registered in Europe in April 2025 against 1,961 a year earlier, had a lot to do with Jaguar phasing out almost its whole range before the new electric models were ready. But the rebrand gave existing fans very little to hold on to while the showrooms sat empty.
Even a small round of testing would have shown how far the new brand had drifted from the people who already loved the old one.
Step 7: Plan the rollout like a project
Rollout is where a lot of good rebrands go wrong. List every place your brand appears, decide what changes on day one and what can follow, and give each item an owner and a date.
- Website, favicon and email signatures
- Social media profiles, cover images and highlight icons
- Google Business Profile and online directories
- Packaging, labels and printed stock, planned around existing inventory
- Signage, vehicles and uniforms
- Invoices, proposals, presentations and contracts
- Legal name, trademarks and domain redirects
If your domain changes, set up permanent 301 redirects from every old page to its new address so you keep your Google rankings. Burger King planned its changes over several years, partly because things like staff uniforms are paid for by franchisees and have to last. Phasing is normal, as long as someone has actually planned the phases.
Step 8: Explain the change to your customers
People accept change much more easily when they understand it. Tell them what is changing, why, and what is staying the same. Show the old and new side by side. If your product, prices and people are unchanged, say that plainly.
Cracker Barrel said it wanted the new look to reflect the variety of guests it serves. That message never reached people before the reaction did. By the time the explanation arrived, customers had already decided what the change meant, and the company backed down. Its stock jumped more than 8 percent after the old logo was restored.
Common rebranding mistakes we see
- Starting with the logo instead of the reason and the strategy.
- Throwing away recognisable assets without checking what customers value.
- Letting a committee vote on every design detail.
- Designing for the presentation instead of for packs, screens and signage.
- Launching quietly and hoping nobody asks why.
- Forgetting web redirects and online listings, then losing search traffic.
FAQ
How long does it take to rebrand a company?
It depends on the scope. A visual refresh can be designed in a few weeks, while a full rebrand with a new name, research and a staged rollout often takes several months. The rollout itself, especially packaging and signage, usually takes longer than the design.
Will rebranding hurt my SEO?
Changing your logo and colours does not affect search rankings. Changing your domain or page addresses can, so map every old URL to a new one with 301 redirects, update your Google Business Profile, and use the change of address tool in Google Search Console.
Is changing the logo the same as rebranding?
A new logo is one part of a rebrand. A proper rebrand also looks at your positioning, your message, your other visual elements and how all of them show up wherever customers meet you.
How do I rebrand without losing customers?
Keep the cues your customers recognise, or evolve them gently. Test the new identity with real customers before launch, and explain the change openly when it goes live. In our experience, a lot of rebrand backlash comes from surprise, so give people the story before they write their own.
Planning a rebrand?
We have spent 15 years helping companies in India, the UAE, Europe, Australia and the USA rebuild their brands, from a small logo refresh to a full new identity with packaging. If you are weighing up a rebrand, our branding team can help you work out whether you need a refresh or a full change before you spend money on design. You can look through our brand identity work, or send us a message about your project.