Let’s talk

Packaging redesign: how to change your pack without losing shoppers

Tropicana lost about a fifth of its sales after a new carton in 2009. Here is how to plan a packaging redesign that keeps the customers you already have.

Packaging redesign: how to change your pack without losing shoppers

In January 2009 Tropicana put its Pure Premium orange juice into a new carton in North America. The orange with the straw stuck in it was gone, the logo had changed and "Pure Premium" gave way to "100% Orange". Within weeks sales had dropped by about 20 per cent, competitors picked up the shoppers, and by late February the company said the old carton was coming back.

Clients still bring that story up in packaging redesign meetings with us, usually as a worry. A packaging redesign keeps your shoppers when it changes what is tired or unclear while protecting the colours, shapes, logo and layout people use to find you on the shelf. Change too many of those at once and regular buyers simply stop seeing you. Here is how to plan one so that does not happen.

Why do packaging redesigns lose shoppers?

Most people do not read packs in a shop. They scan. A regular buyer of your product is looking for a colour block, a shape or a picture they already know, and they find it in a second or two. When that cue disappears, they do not stop to study the new design. They grab the competitor whose pack still looks the way they remember.

Tropicana is the famous case, but it is not the only one. The German biscuit maker Bahlsen launched a new look in 2021 that won a global D&AD award. According to Adelaide University's summary of research by Dr William Caruso at the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute, sales then fell by around 12 per cent and the brand lost category leadership in several markets, despite a design the industry rated highly.

Caruso's doctoral work looked at 1,336 redesigns from 744 brands across 25 categories, and a summary in Plastics Engineering reports that around nine in ten failed to deliver a meaningful sales lift. The redesigned packs were, on average, only about 47 per cent similar to the designs they replaced. Asking a loyal customer to absorb half a new pack in one go is a big ask.

Should you redesign your packaging at all?

Ask this first, because a surprising number of redesigns start for the wrong reason. Adelaide University reports that 58 per cent of marketers named modernisation as the main purpose of their most recent redesign. "It looks dated" is often how the marketing team feels after looking at the same pack every day for five years. Your customers have not been staring at it.

We would push back on the common advice that you should refresh packaging every few years as a matter of routine. Caruso's own advice is to modernise only when there is evidence that people like the pack less than they used to. Good reasons to redesign tend to look more like this:

  • You are moving into a new channel, such as from local shops to supermarket chains or to Amazon, where the pack has to work as a tiny thumbnail.
  • Shoppers keep picking the wrong variant because flavours or sizes look too similar.
  • The product itself has changed, and the pack no longer tells people what is inside.
  • New labelling rules or a change of material force a layout change anyway.
  • Sales data or research shows the pack is losing ground, and you can point to why.

If none of those apply, a smaller fix may be enough. Sometimes the right answer after a review is to leave the pack alone, and a good studio should be willing to tell you that.

What should you keep when you redesign packaging?

Before anyone sketches a new layout, list your distinctive brand assets. These are the things shoppers link to you without needing to read your name: a particular colour, a mascot, a bottle shape, a pattern, the position of the logo, a type style. The Tropicana orange and straw was one of these. So is the Coca-Cola red, or the green of a Heineken bottle.

Then find out which of them actually work. That means testing with real category buyers, not asking your team which ones they are fond of. A distinctive asset is only useful if a good share of shoppers connect it to your brand and not to a competitor.

Caruso ran a small experiment that shows why this matters. With 400 people in each of the US and the UK, he showed unbranded mint packs in different styles, and the very minimal option did reasonably well on its own. Once real brand cues were added, the picture changed. In the US, 87 per cent chose the pack carrying Mentos branding over the minimal version. In the UK, 74 per cent chose the Trebor-branded pack.

In our studio we usually sort assets into three groups when a client asks for a redesign: protect, improve, and free to change. The first group is short and almost never touched. The second gets refined, perhaps a cleaner version of the same colour or a redrawn mascot. Everything else, from the back panel copy to the claims hierarchy, is open.

How much change is too much in a packaging redesign?

There is no safe percentage, but the direction of the evidence is clear. Change in steps. If your pack has a strong colour and a recognisable logo position, keep both and work on the rest. If you want a bigger change, spread it over two or three updates so shoppers move with you.

The reported Plastics Engineering figures put it in numbers: a quarter of revolutionary redesigns led to lower purchase rates than the packs they replaced, and evolutionary changes did so at about half that rate. Bold redesigns did bring shopping benefits more often, so they are not always wrong. They just carry more risk, and you should only take that risk when the brand really needs it, for example after a merger or when the old pack is actively hurting sales.

A quick test we use: put the old and new pack side by side at thumbnail size and squint. If a regular buyer would not know they are the same product, you have gone too far for one step.

How to test a packaging redesign before launch

Focus groups are still the default way many brands check a new pack, and we think they are a weak guide. A study of 227 marketers by Caruso, Jenni Romaniuk and colleagues, reported in Research Live, found focus groups were linked to less successful redesigns. Research that measured distinctive brand assets was linked to more successful ones. The same study found no evidence that shelf tests or time-to-find scores predicted success.

So put your testing money where it counts:

  1. Test your current assets with category buyers to see which ones are truly linked to you.
  2. Test the new design's version of those assets to make sure they still carry the link.
  3. Check that the pack tells shoppers the main thing they look for in your category. Designalytics, which measures thousands of pack designs, reports that communicating the most important category attributes correlates 88 per cent with sales performance.
  4. Keep "no change" as a real option in the research, so the team is not just choosing between new designs.

None of this needs a huge budget for a small brand. Even a simple online test with a few hundred category buyers will tell you more than a room of eight people reacting to boards.

How do you launch new packaging without confusing shoppers?

A redesign can fail even when the design is right, because the shelf, the website and the retailer's app still show the old pack. Zappi described a shopper who was told a baby formula was out of stock because the shelf card showed the old packaging. It was on the shelf all along, in the new design.

Plan the switch as carefully as the design:

  • Update every product image at once: your site, Amazon, Blinkit or Instacart listings, supermarket portals and Google Shopping.
  • Send retailers and distributors the new images and barcodes early, with dates.
  • Use "new look, same product" messaging on pack or shelf for the first few months.
  • Support the launch with some advertising. Ehrenberg-Bass research summarised by Plastics Engineering links in-store and digital advertising support with better results after a redesign.
  • Watch sales weekly for the first three months and be ready to adjust quickly.

What does a packaging redesign that works look like?

The good stories are less famous because nothing went wrong. Designalytics lists several measured lifts after redesigns: the frozen dumpling brand Laoban reported sales up 296 per cent, Organic Valley about 10 per cent in six months and Nuun 7.9 per cent. In most of these cases the brand made its category message clearer and its pack easier to spot, without throwing away what buyers already recognised.

That matches what we see with food, spice and cosmetics clients in Kerala and with founders further afield. The redesigns that do well usually fix one clear problem, such as variants that look alike or a benefit nobody can read from a metre away. The ones that struggle try to fix everything at once because a new marketing head wants a fresh start.

Packaging redesign checklist

  1. Write down the business reason for the redesign in one sentence. If you cannot, pause.
  2. List and test your distinctive brand assets.
  3. Decide what to protect, what to improve and what is free to change.
  4. Brief the designer with sales data, competitor packs and the channels you sell in.
  5. Test the new pack against the old one with real category buyers.
  6. Plan the rollout across shelves, listings and retailer systems.
  7. Track sales weekly after launch and agree in advance what would make you change course.

If you are working with a studio in India from the US, Australia, Ireland, New Zealand or Finland, this process works well remotely. Most of the testing is online, and we usually set up a couple of overlapping hours each week for reviews. Print proofs are the one stage where it helps to have someone near the printer, which is something to agree on early.

FAQ

How often should you redesign product packaging?

There is no fixed cycle. Redesign when something has changed: your channels, your product, labelling rules, or evidence that shoppers like the pack less. Many strong brands make small refinements every few years and keep their core cues for decades.

How long does a packaging redesign take?

For a small range, expect roughly two to four months from brief to print-ready files, depending on how much testing you do and how many variants there are. Printing, retailer approvals and selling through old stock can add more time, so plan the launch date backwards from those.

What is the difference between a packaging refresh and a redesign?

A refresh keeps the structure and main brand cues and tidies everything around them, such as type, photography or claims. A redesign changes the layout or some core cues as well. A refresh carries much less risk of losing regular buyers.

Should a small brand test packaging before launch?

Yes, at least lightly. A short online test with buyers in your category, focused on whether they recognise your brand and understand what the product is, costs far less than reprinting after a launch that confuses people.

Planning a packaging redesign?

If your pack needs work and you do not want to lose the customers you already have, we can help you work out what to keep and what to change before any design starts. See our packaging design work and services, look through recent projects, or send us a note about your product. We are based in Kozhikode and work with brands in India and overseas.